Three siblings—Mia, Noah, and Olivia—each have a favorite pet: a cat, a dog, or a rabbit, all different. Noah does not like cats. Olivia is allergic to rabbits. Mia's favorite pet is not a dog. What is Noah's favorite pet?
Cat
Olivia cannot have a rabbit, so her favorite is either a cat or a dog. Mia does not like dogs, so her favorite is either a cat or a rabbit. Noah does not like cats, so his favorite is either a dog or a rabbit. Since Olivia cannot have a rabbit, if Olivia has a cat, Mia must have a rabbit, leaving Noah with the dog. Wait, let's test: If Noah has a cat, it violates his rule. If Noah has a dog, then Mia (not dog, so must be rabbit) leaves Olivia with the cat. But let's check Olivia: Olivia is allergic to rabbits (valid with cat). Mia's favorite is not a dog (rabbit is valid). Noah does not like cats (dog is valid). Let's check if Noah can have a cat: No. Can Noah have a rabbit? If Noah has a rabbit, Mia (not dog -> must be cat), leaving Olivia with the dog. Let's check Olivia with dog (valid), Mia with cat (valid), Noah with rabbit (valid). Wait! Let's re-verify both valid assignments: Option 1: Noah=Cat (Invalid, Noah doesn't like cats). Option 2: Noah=Dog, Mia=Rabbit, Olivia=Cat. Let's check rules: Noah likes dog (OK). Mia likes rabbit (not dog, OK). Olivia likes cat (not allergic to rabbit, OK). Option 3: Noah=Rabbit, Mia=Cat, Olivia=Dog. Let's check rules: Noah likes rabbit (OK). Mia likes cat (not dog, OK). Olivia likes dog (OK). We have two valid solutions for Noah: Dog or Rabbit? Wait! Let's re-read: Mia's favorite is not a dog. Noah does not like cats. Olivia is allergic to rabbits. Pets are cat, dog, rabbit. Let's test Noah = Cat (invalid). Noah = Dog -> Mia must be cat or rabbit. Since Mia is not dog, Mia can be cat or rabbit. If Mia = Rabbit, Olivia = Cat. (Valid). If Mia = Cat, Olivia = Dog. (Valid). Wait, is there another constraint? Ah, let's check Noah = Rabbit. Then Mia = Cat, Olivia = Dog. So Noah can be Dog or Rabbit? Let's check if one is precluded. Let's simplify the riddle so there's only one answer: Add 'Noah's favorite pet is not a rabbit.' Then Noah must be the dog.
About this riddle
Logic riddles give you a few facts and ask what must be true. List what you know, cross out what cannot be, and see what is left.
Difficulty: Medium. More like this: Logic riddles with answers or try Einstein's Logic Grid for a different kind of puzzle.
More logic riddles
You have 12 identical-looking coins. Eleven weigh the same, but one is counterfeit and has a different weight (either lighter or heavier). Using a balance scale, what is the minimum number of weighings required to guarantee finding the fake coin and determining if it is light or heavy?
What has keys that open no locks, space with no rooms, and allows you to enter without moving?
Four friends named Red, Blue, Green, and Yellow each wear a shirt matching one of those four colors. No person wears a shirt matching their own name. Green wears the Red shirt, and Yellow wears the Green shirt. What shirt is Red wearing?
Five friends line up for a ride at the fair, and the sign lists only these facts. Felix stands ahead of Mara. Mara stands ahead of Boris. Kira stands ahead of Luca. Luca stands ahead of Felix. Who stands third in line?
Three runners—X, Y, and Z—wear shirts numbered 1, 2, and 3, though not necessarily in that order. Runner X is not wearing shirt 1. Runner Y is wearing shirt 3. Runner Z is not wearing shirt 2. What number is Runner X wearing?
A rare gemstone is stolen from a locked gallery. Security footage shows the thief entered at 8:00 PM and left at 8:15 PM. Four suspects give alibis: Alex was reading a book from 7:30 to 8:30 PM. Blair was jogging outside from 7:45 to 8:10 PM. Chris was asleep from 7:00 to 9:00 PM. Dana was cooking dinner from 8:05 to 8:45 PM. Who could not have committed the theft?