Sir Sterling was poisoned at his birthday dinner. Everyone ate the same meal, but only his wine was laced with arsenic. The sommelier swore he poured it straight from a sealed bottle. Detective Drake checked the empty bottle's foil seal and made an arrest. What was wrong with the seal?
The seal was pierced from underneath
If a bottle is truly sealed, poison cannot enter. The foil seal had a tiny puncture underneath where a syringe had injected the poison without breaking the top cap.
About this riddle
Detective riddles are tiny mysteries. Look for the detail in the story that does not fit; it is usually the clue that solves the case.
Difficulty: Medium. More like this: Detective riddles with answers or try Truth & Lie Island for a different kind of puzzle.
More detective riddles
A security guard reported a break-in at a high-tech lab. He claimed he was knocked unconscious from behind by an intruder wearing heavy boots. Detective Sterling examined the guard's uniform and noticed the back of his shirt was completely dry while the rest of him was drenched in sweat from a humid summer night. Sterling arrested the guard for staging the break-in. Why?
A museum curator was found bound to a chair with his own pocket watch chain. The safe was wide open. Three suspects were interviewed: The art dealer, who was wearing heavy winter gloves indoors; the accountant, who had fresh ink stains on his cheek; and the gardener, who had dirt under his fingernails. Detective Hayes asked for their coats. Whose coat proved their guilt?
Five guests sign the hotel log one by one, and the manager remembers only these facts. Carmen signed before Nico. Mara signed before Carmen. Nico signed before Kira. Kira signed before Aria. Who signed first?
Sir Arthur was found dead in his study on a crisp autumn morning. The window was wide open, and dry maple leaves littered the carpet. The butler stated he opened the window at dawn to air out the room. Detective Meyer checked the window frame, shook his head, and accused the butler of murder. Why?
The victim left a dying message scratched into the dust on the floor: '12-5-5-19'. Detective Frost didn't need a computer to decode it. What word did the numbers spell out?
An explorer was found dead inside his tent in the Sahara Desert. The tent flap was zipped shut from the inside, and there were no tracks around the tent. Inside, his canteen was full and his pack was untouched. The local guide took one look inside and said he died of thirst. How is that possible?