An emerald necklace was stolen from a duchess during a masked ball. Three guests wearing identical black domino masks were detained: Lord Henry, Lady Clara, and Count Dante. Detective Vance asked them what song the orchestra was playing when the lights went out. Lord Henry said a waltz; Lady Clara said a tango; Count Dante said a jazz tune. Vance instantly knew who stole the necklace. Who was it?
Count Dante
The ball was a traditional Victorian masquerade playing classical music; jazz tunes were not invented or played at such formal historical events, exposing the Count's lie.
About this riddle
Detective riddles are tiny mysteries. Look for the detail in the story that does not fit; it is usually the clue that solves the case.
Difficulty: Medium. More like this: Detective riddles with answers or try Truth & Lie Island for a different kind of puzzle.
More detective riddles
A suspect claimed he spent all night reading a single book under the glow of a streetlamp outside his apartment. Detective Green looked at the suspect's clean, unblemished white shirt and immediately knew he was lying. Why?
Detective Reed found a victim in a locked walk-in freezer. The heavy metal door was bolted from the outside. The temperature inside was well below freezing, yet the victim's body was completely soaked in warm water. How is this possible?
Three kids race to build the tallest rabbit tower. Zoe finished before Ana. Ida finished before Zoe. Who finished last?
The elf says the gift is not in a red box, not in a small box and not tied with a blue ribbon. The boxes are: big red, big green with blue ribbon, big green with gold ribbon, small blue. Which one holds it?
A jewelry store clerk reported a smash-and-grab robbery. He claimed a masked man broke the display glass with a hammer, grabbed a tray of gold rings, and fled out the back alley. Detective Hayes examined the broken glass counter and found that all the shattered glass pieces had fallen outward onto the store floor, away from the display case. Hayes arrested the clerk. Why?
A famous concert pianist was found murdered in her dressing room right before a major performance. The room had three closed windows and one heavy oak door bolted from the inside. On the dressing table sat a metronome still ticking rhythmically, a glass of water, and an unsealed envelope containing a threatening letter. Detective Sterling noticed something impossible about the room's environment and deduced the killer had been there long after the door was bolted. What was it?