An ancient manuscript was stolen from a glass case during a massive blackout. The lights went out for exactly three minutes. When power returned, the case was empty. Three guards were on duty: Guard A was eating a sandwich, Guard B was holding a flashlight, and Guard C was listening to the radio. Detective Sterling arrested Guard B. Why?
Guard B was holding a flashlight during a blackout, which would have allowed them to see and steal the manuscript while everyone else was blinded by total darkness.
Having an active light source in total darkness provides both the motive and opportunity to navigate and steal unseen.
About this riddle
Detective riddles are tiny mysteries. Look for the detail in the story that does not fit; it is usually the clue that solves the case.
Difficulty: Easy. More like this: Detective riddles with answers or try Truth & Lie Island for a different kind of puzzle.
More detective riddles
Detective Briggs examined the body of a man found face down in a shallow indoor swimming pool. The victim's wristwatch was broken and stopped at 3:15 PM. His pockets were full of heavy river stones. The pool was empty of water, but the surrounding tile floor was soaking wet. Briggs concluded the man did not drown. Why?
During a blackout, a diamond necklace vanished from a hotel suite. The suspect claimed she was sitting in total darkness reading her favorite paperback novel. The detective smiled and slapped the cuffs on her wrists. What gave her away?
The famous singer Maria was found dead in her dressing room before a big concert. The room was locked from the inside. On her vanity mirror, scrawled in lipstick, was the name 'MARK'. Detective Silva suspected Mark, but Mark produced a watertight alibi: he was on a live television broadcast three miles away when she died. Silva smiled and arrested Mark anyway. How did Mark commit the murder with an alibi?
A famous chef was found slumped over a cutting board. The medical examiner said he died instantly of a heart attack while slicing garlic. Detective Miller noticed the garlic cloves were sliced into perfect, uniform cubes. Miller arrested the sous chef. What tipped him off?
An explorer claimed he was attacked in the jungle by a rare nocturnal predator at high noon. Detective Reed didn't even let him finish his story before calling security. What error did the explorer make?
A renowned scientist was found dead in her subterranean laboratory. The security logs showed she entered at 8 PM and never left. The cause of death was dehydration. Her assistant claimed he hadn't seen her since noon that day. Detective Dale examined the sealed lab, saw a fully functioning sink, a water cooler, and an unblemished glass on the desk. He immediately arrested the assistant for conspiracy. Why?