A suspect told Detective Miller he spent the entire stormy night driving along the coastal highway with his headlights on to guide his way. Miller checked the car and arrested him on the spot. What was wrong with his story?
It was daytime
The suspect claimed he drove along the highway all night, but also mentioned using his headlights 'to guide his way' during a daytime storm? Wait, the riddle says 'stormy night'. Let's refine: He claimed he saw the sunset in the east.
About this riddle
Detective riddles are tiny mysteries. Look for the detail in the story that does not fit; it is usually the clue that solves the case.
Difficulty: Easy. More like this: Detective riddles with answers or try Truth & Lie Island for a different kind of puzzle.
More detective riddles
Inspector Drake examined a threatening letter cut out from a glossy magazine. The letters were pasted unevenly. Drake noticed a tiny speck of fresh pink nail polish on the back of the word 'Danger.' Who in the office did he question first?
A rare diamond was stolen from a glass display case. The security guard swore he never left his post facing the case, and the only other person in the gallery was a famous sculptor who stood completely still molding clay for two hours. Vance noticed the sculptor's hands were caked in dry plaster, yet a tiny speck of diamond dust sat on the sculptor's eyelid. Who is the thief?
Inspector Frost is checking the order in which five suspects left the locked library. Felix left before Opal. Opal left before Carmen. Kira left before Gwen. Gwen left before Felix. Who left fourth?
Detective Sterling arrived at a high-end art gallery. A painting was stolen, and the frame was left empty on the wall. Three staff members were present: the curator, the janitor, and the accountant. Each blamed the other. Sterling looked at their shoes: the curator had pristine shoes, the janitor had sawdust on his soles, and the accountant had red clay on his heels. The stolen painting was a watercolor of a desert canyon. Who took it?
Detective Miller found a coded diary next to a poisoned diplomat. The cipher substitution was simple: every letter shifted forward by three. The final sentence read: 'THE ENEMY HAS ARRIVED AT DAWN.' Miller immediately realized the diary was a forgery planted by the diplomat's secretary. What was the flaw in the diary?
Inspector Fox walked into a hotel room where a tourist was found bound and gagged. The room safe was open and empty. The tourist babbled frantically through his tape gag, pointing at a calendar marked with today's date: July 15th. Fox untaped him, listened to his wild story about masked men, and then slapped handcuffs on the tourist. Why?