A famous pianist was found strangled in her dressing room. The killer left behind a music sheet with notes written in a bizarre cipher. The manager claimed he couldn't read music at all. Detective Ray looked at the cipher, pointed out that the notes spelled out a secret message, and arrested the manager. How did Ray know the manager lied?
The manager set up the sheet
The manager claimed he couldn't read music at all. However, to frame someone or leave a cipher in musical notes, the person must know how to place notes on a staff. Furthermore, if he couldn't read music, how did he instantly recognize that the paper contained a secret message instead of just a standard song?
About this riddle
Detective riddles are tiny mysteries. Look for the detail in the story that does not fit; it is usually the clue that solves the case.
Difficulty: Medium. More like this: Detective riddles with answers or try Truth & Lie Island for a different kind of puzzle.
More detective riddles
An antique dealer was murdered. Three suspects were interviewed. The delivery driver said he dropped off a heavy oak table. The appraiser said he valued a silver goblet. The neighbor said she heard a gunshot at 2:00 PM. Detective Hayes arrested the delivery driver immediately. Why?
The security guard was found tied to a chair in the vault, claiming a masked intruder locked him up and stole the diamond. The vault door was locked from the outside with a mechanical deadbolt. However, the guard's wristwatch was missing, and the ticking of the watch could be heard clearly from inside a sealed glass display case across the room. How did the detective know the guard was lying?
A security guard at a high-tech vault claims he was knocked unconscious from behind while on his midnight patrol. When investigators arrived, they found his flashlight smashed, his uniform pristine, and his shoes tied in double knots. Detective Hall smiled and charged the guard with insurance fraud. What betrayed the guard's lie?
Detective Novak questions five witnesses about the order they reached the museum door. Kira reached the door before Mara. Hugo reached the door before Iris. Iris reached the door before Carmen. Mara reached the door before Hugo. Who reached the door last?
Detective Drake entered a freezing cold cabin where a man sat shivering by an unlit fireplace. The victim claimed someone broke in and stole his only box of matches. Drake looked at the man's hands and arrested him for arson at a nearby building. What did Drake see?
A priceless golden chalice was stolen from a cathedral. The thief left behind a muddy boot print near the altar. Investigator Rossi compared the print to the three church custodians. Custodian Lee has a size 10 boot with a star tread. Custodian Grant has a size 12 boot with a square tread. Custodian Nash has a size 8 boot with a circular tread. The print at the scene was a size 10 with a square tread. Rossi smiled. What does this mismatch tell him?